What Is The Fluffiest Down Alternative Comforter Around?

The weather is getting colder. It’s time to start looking for the fluffiest down alternative comforter. There are plenty of options. Which is the best option for you? My top 5 picks will keep you snug and warm during the colder months. 

Some people love the soft, warm feeling of a goose down comforter. For some people, goose or duck down stuffing just doesn’t work. These comforters can cause allergic reactions. They can be expensive. They are sourced, rather cruelly, from live animals.
 
I’m allergic to down. I dislike the practice of plucking feathers of live ducks and geese. But I wanted that soft, warm feeling snuggling under a comforter in winter. And I found it after much research. Here are my top 5 fluffiest, healthy, ethical goose down alternatives. They feel just as comfortable as the real thing.

Brand/ModelNumber of Amazon Reviews
1 Lavish Comforts ULTIMATE Goose Down Alternative Duvet Insert 230
2 Homfy Down Alternative Quilted Cover 65
3 Mandarin Home Bamboo Comforter with Goose Down Alternative Fill 140
4 Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter 560
5 Organic Textiles Bamboo Fiber Filled Luxury Comforter 7

Table of Contents

Don’t have time to read my complete guide to the fluffiest down alternative comforter? Just click on the headings below. That way you can skim through the post. 

Why Choose A Down Alternative Comforter?

Down alternative has some serious advantages over goose or duck down, such as:

  • Affordability
  • Lack of animal products
  • Less allergenic, and in some cases completely hypoallergenic.

With all these great benefits, many smart consumers like you choose down alternative comforters. However, not all down alternative comforters are equally fluffy, warm, and comfortable. The wide choice available and variation from one comforter to the next cam be confusing.

My guide to the fluffiest down alternative comforter will help you.

What Causes Differences in Down Alternative Products?

Manufacturing quality and care makes a big difference. Better-made comforters are fluffy. They will retain their shape and warmth for longer.

The type of material used also makes a big difference. Non down comforters use a wide variety of materials to feel and function like a down comforter.

Common materials include:

  • Polyester
  • Bamboo
  • Rayon
  • Tencel and other wood fibers
  • Cotton
  • Other natural and synthetic materials.

These materials differ in quality. This will influence your preference. Your own personal likes and dislikes will also shape your choice of which material is better.

Do you have an allergy to polyester, rayon or any other synthetic materials? Then be very careful when buying your down alternative comforter.

Buying Criteria For The Fluffiest Down Alternative Comforters

In this section, I will present a couple of key questions. Keep these in mind and will have a much easier time deciding which of the top products is right for you.

Is Organic Important to You?

If you prefer buying organic, there are a few benefits and drawbacks to consider.

ProsCons
Considered to be better for the environment than synthetic products. Can be more expensive,
Some consumers find organic down alternative comforters to be fluffier and more durable.

The only major drawback of buying organic is the increased price. It’s more expensive because organic farming and manufacturing are usually much more expensive.

Who is the Product For?

Important things to keep in mind include allergies, sleeping style, and level of care required for products.

Allergies

Do you have allergies to a particular material—plant-based or synthetic? Then check carefully for that material before making a purchase. 

Sleeping Style

Do you prefer to sleep with a warmer or lighter blanket?

Down and down alternative comforters seek to combine high warmth with a low weight. This means there can be a lot of variation in how warm and how heavy they are.

If you are a hot sleeper, you may want a comforter that’s lightweight even for a down alternative product. Consider these comforters to stay cool in winter.

hot sleeper

Are you a cold sleeper? Live in a very cold environment? Prefer heavier bedding while you sleep? They you will want more filling in the comforter. You should also buy a thicker duvet cover with your new down alternative comforter. Think of a cotton flannel duvet cover.

Care

How much effort are you willing and able to put into caring for your down alternative comforter? All high-quality products should be taken good care of, but some require a lot more work than others. 

If you travel often, work long hours, or have young children, you want to get a comforter that will hold up without much maintenance.

Keep these things in mind:

  • Synthetic materials are often more durable than natural ones.
  • Getting a comforter with a harder outer cover, or covering a down alternative duvet with a very strong duvet cover, will make it more physically durable.

My Review Of The Fluffiest Down Alternative Comforters Around

Lavish Comforts Ultimate Goose Down Alternative Duvet Insert

ProsCons
Synthetic material is hypoallergenic Not an organic or eco-friendly option
Very affordable Does not include a cover
Machine washable Not made in US
Easy to care for Is not extremely durable

The Lavish Comfort is one of the most affordable comforter on my Top 5 list. It is also very popular.
 
This fluffy comforter can be machine-washed.
 
The box-stitching construction keeps the filling from moving around or bunching up after many washes.
The synthetic material is a drawback for people who want an organic option.
 
While I listed the fact that this product doesn’t include a duvet cover as a con, it can be seen as a pro in some ways. You can choose your own duvet cover that fits your needs as well as your personal style. For example, if you are a cold sleeper, choose a duvet cover made with a heavier material. The opposite applies for hot sleepers.  
Amazon customers found the Lavish Comfort both fluffy and breathable. But some did say that it is very warm. This means it may not be a good choice for those of you who live in hot climates or sleep hot.
 
This comforter is imported from China. This has a positive impact on the price. If you want to support US manufacturing, this feature is not great.

Made in the uSA

Homfy Down Alternative Quilted Comforter With Cover

ProsCons
Machine washable Not an organic or eco-friendly option
100% cotton cover Does not include a cover
Includes a warranty Not made in US
Hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant Is not extremely durable

This Homfy comforter is the middle ground between quality and price. It is also part natural and synthetic.
 
Its 100% cotton cover keeps it comfortable and natural-feeling on the outside.
 
The cotton cover also makes this product more breathable. This benefits people who sleep hot. But if you live in a very cold climate (Alaska, Canada, etc.), this comforter may not be enough on its own.
 
The synthetic filling imitates down quite well and keeps the price low.
While this isn’t the cheapest product on my Top 5 list, it isn’t very expensive either. It is one of the best value options around.
 
This product is definitely machine washable. But from the customer reviews I read online, the Homfy won’t hold up to a lot of heat during drying. Dry it only using your dryer’s lowest heat setting. Check on it often. Better yet, let it dry in the sun to make it last even longer!

Mandarin Home Bamboo Comforter with Goose Down Alternative Fill

ProsCons
Minimalist style goes with everything Not extremely durable
Wrinkle and stain resistant Not made in US
Hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant Requires a bit of extra care when drying
Balances warmth and low weight Will not work with a regular duvet cover
Not an organic option. And cover made with bamboo rayon.

The Mandarin Home Bamboo Comforter has a bamboo rayon cover and a polyester filling.
 
If you are a regular reader of this blog. you know that I don’t like bamboo rayon. It may sound natural but it’s not. Bamboo rayon starts off natural with the pulp from bamboo. But then that pulp is dissolved into cellulose using strong chemical solvents. You can read more about here.
 
On a positive note, the choice of material keeps this comforter at a very low weight.
 
It is also hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant. This comforter is not recommended for those people with an allergy to bamboo.
It has the added benefit of wrinkle and stain resistance. This feature can save you hours washing, spot-cleaning, and ironing.
 
The gray cover with a simple box-stitching, means it will match with anything. This comforter will not fit most duvet covers. The cover is built-in with the comforter as a single unit. You can’t add a duvet cover on top to customize the look to your tastes and preferences.
 
The major downside to this product is its lack of durability. Its bamboo cover is more prone to tears than some other materials. While it’s not exactly weak, it will require some extra care.
 
To care for the Mandarin comforter in the best way, place it in the sun to dry. Alternatively, tumble dry on the lowest heat. Any exposed threads should be immediately cut to prevent fraying.

Pinzon Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter

ProsCons
Cotton cover A bit pricey
Made in the USA Filling can get knocked out of shape easily
Machine washable and dryable Can be too warm for some people
Oeko-Tex Factory Certification

Pinzon also seeks to combine the best of the synthetic and the natural with a 100% cotton cover and a polyester filling. The cotton cover of this fluffy down alternative cover is exceptionally soft, but the price of this comforter is a bit high for some consumers.

In addition, some people have complained that this comforter is too warm for them. I would not recommend this product for hot sleepers. That being said, the extra warmth can feel amazing in cold climates, and perhaps even help you save energy (and money) by using less air conditioning.

While this product is completely ready for the washer and dryer, it’s not as durable as some might expect at this price point. While the outer cover is quite well constructed, the filling can often be knocked out of place inside, and clump up in certain spots rather than filling the whole blanket evenly.

One major benefit that conscientious consumers will be happy with is the product’s Oeko-Tex Factory Certification.

Organic Textiles Bamboo Fiber Filled Luxury Comforter

ProsCons
GOTS certified-organic cotton cover Much higher than average price
US-Based Manufacturer Difficult to wash
All natural bamboo and tencel filling Can be too cool for some climates
Mite resistant Too thin for some customers
Ultra-lightweight and perfect for hot sleepers
Durable construction with piped edges

Organic Textiles has created an all-natural down alternative comforter.

The price is steeper than that of any other down alternative comforter in this buyers’ guide. However, much of the high price can be explained by the more expensive and labor intensive high quality natural materials.

It’s hypoallergenic like the other comforters on my Top 5 fluffiest down alternative comforter list. But it offers superior mite resistance compared to the others. However, you should note that if you have an allergy to eucalyptus, you should not use this product, as tencel is derived naturally from the eucalyptus tree.

This comfort’s extremely low weight and generally cooler feel is a blessing for some customers and a curse for others. While this is definitely a great down alternative comforter for hot sleepers, it may not be great for those living in very cold climates or who want an extremely thick down alternative blanket.

While this product is machine washable, the manufacturer advises that it may be too large for many conventional washing machines. For drying, air dry is recommended, though the product can tolerate a tumble dry at a very low heat.

Last but not least, this US-based manufacturer’s GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standards) certification will certainly bring organically-focused consumers peace of mind. This certifies that the cotton cover is organic.

Comparing the Fluffiest Down Comforters

Lavish ComfortsHomfyMandarin HomePinzonOrganic Textiles
Natural or synthetic?SyntheticNatural cover, synthetic fillingNatural cover, synthetic fillingNatural cover, synthetic fillingOrganic cover, natural filling
Washer and dryer safe?Washer-safe, dry at low heatWasher safe, dry at low heatWasher safe, drying in sun recommendedWasher safe, drying in sun recommendedSafe for some washers, drying in the sun strongly recommended
ManufactureImportedImportedImportedMade in USA with Oeko-Tex certificationUS-based manufacturer with GOTS certification
Price range*Under $75Under $100Under $75Under $125Under $200

*Price ranges specified are for Queen or Full/Queen sizes. Smaller sizes will be cheaper, and larger sizes more expensive.

Caring For Your Comforter

Fluffy down alternative comforters can involve a little more maintenance. Your efforts will be worth it. Your comforter will feel softer, retain heat better, and most of all last longer.

Follow all instructions on product care labels carefully.

Here are my care tips:
– If your comforter is machine washable and dryer safe, be careful. Use the lowest settings.
– If your comforter is dryer safe, dry it in the sun.
– Trim any exposed threads so that the comforter does not begin to unravel.

Using these tips will maintain the size and shape of your comforter, and keep the filling distributed evenly. I hate a lumpy comforter!

The Advantages of Buying From Amazon

  • Buyers can rate the products they purchase. This helps you know whether the product will be good or not.
  • Amazon Prime members have exclusive benefits. For example, free 2 day delivery on eligible items. 

You can buy my top 5 fluffiest down alternative comforters on Amazon.com.

What Is The Best Fluffiest Down Alternative Comforter?

The Best-All Rounder is the Organic Textiles Bamboo Fiber Filled Luxury Comforter. It has superior feel. The manufacturing standards are solid. This comforter would be the best for hot sleepers.

Check out the Organic Textiles Comforter as the best all rounder

The Best Value option is the Homfy Comforter. It is not the cheapest comforter but it packs in a lot of value. It is still under half the price of the Organic Textiles choice.

Click here for more information about the Homfy Best Value Comforter with Cover

Do you feel the cold when you sleep? Live in a very cold climate? Then finally I will recommend the Pinzon comforter. This down alternative comforter was the warmest of all. Live in more tropical or temperate areas? Then don’t buy the Pinzon.

Check out the Amazon customer reviews Pinzon Hypoallergenic Comforter here

I hope this buying guide helped you find the fluffiest down alternative comforter to suit your needs.

Enjoy your new bedding!

May the zzz’s be with you!

Michelle